- Microsoft research projects to improve our lives
- Outlook '09
- IBM employees buzzing about layoff rumors
- AT&T builds $23M IPv6 network for U.S. military
- Is VoIP dead?
My problem with broadband? It's the lack of real choice.
Currently what we have is the kind of "choice" offered by fast food companies selling third-rate beef wrapped in chemical-laden buns who try to persuade you that you can have it your way when the choice is little more than with or without onions.
What I'm talking about is real choice, the kind of choice that shows that the world of commerce is a level playing field and it isn't just a case of he who has the most money gets to squeeze the market dry.
I have complained many times about the lack of choice in Internet access and people have argued that if you can switch service providers then there is choice. I contend that when switching is painful – when there are penalties or delays or other impediments – then choice is illusory.
So, what do we need to foster an Internet connectivity marketplace with real choice? It’s obvious: A broader playing field with low entry barriers so there are more competitors.
Much to my surprise, and the surprise of many others, the FCC has just taken what could be a step forward by approving the use of "White Spaces" as an alternative for Internet access.
White Spaces is the term for the radio spectrum that will be vacated next February when the FCC mandates that analog television broadcasters transmitting from 54MHz to 806MHz go digital and restrict their transmissions to the range 54MHz to 698MHz. That frees up a band 208MHz wide which is a lot of radio capacity to just have lying around.
Commerce, just like nature, abhors a vacuum, so into this opportunity stepped a consortium of power players, namely Microsoft, Google, Dell, HP, Intel, Philips, Earthlink, and Samsung Electro-Mechanics calling themselves the White Spaces Coalition.
The Coalition's proposal is to use the White Spaces for wireless Internet connectivity that will start at 10Mbps and in short range applications may achieve 50M to 100Mbps.
Of course vested interests -- such as television companies, the National Association of Broadcasters and companies that sell wireless audio systems -- all argued that allowing unlicensed use of these frequencies would compromise the integrity of their transmissions. After an 18-month study the FCC concluded these naysayers were full of it so on Nov. 4, U.S. election day, the FCC voted unanimously to allow unlicensed use of approved devices operating in the White Spaces.
Comment